Archive
The Paradox of Progress: Technology, Penmanship, and the Authenticity of Writing
The relentless march of technological advancement has undeniably revolutionized education, offering students unprecedented access to information and tools. Yet, this progress has inadvertently created a paradoxical challenge: a decline in penmanship among students, even as the demand for legible handwriting resurfaces in the age of artificial intelligence. From the observation of my own students, ranging from middle school to high school, to the increasing prevalence of typing practice over handwriting in younger children, it is evident that the art of crafting letters by hand is waning. This trend, however, clashes starkly with the evolving landscape of college admissions, where institutions are increasingly emphasizing authentic, on-the-spot writing skills as a countermeasure to AI-generated content.
The digital age has fostered a culture where typing and digital communication reign supreme. Students are adept at navigating keyboards and touchscreens, but the physical act of writing with a pen or pencil seems to be falling by the wayside. This is particularly concerning given the cognitive benefits associated with handwriting, including improved memory, fine motor skills, and creative thinking. Yet, the emphasis on digital literacy in early education, exemplified by my 6th-grade niece’s focus on typing, reflects a broader societal shift towards prioritizing technological proficiency.
Ironically, as AI tools become increasingly sophisticated, institutions of higher learning are recognizing the need to reassert the value of authentic, human-generated work. The surge in AI-assisted writing has prompted many elite colleges and universities to implement new evaluation methods that prioritize spontaneous, handwritten responses. This shift is not a regression, but rather an adaptation to ensure that students possess genuine critical thinking and communication skills, qualities that remain uniquely human.
Institutions like MIT, Georgetown, and the University of California system have begun incorporating timed writing assessments, maker portfolios, and spontaneous response questions into their application processes. These methods are designed to assess a student’s ability to think critically and express themselves clearly under pressure, without the aid of pre-prepared or AI-generated content. For example, Yale University’s use of video response questions and the University of Chicago’s reliance on unexpected creative prompts during interviews push applicants to engage with material in real-time, revealing their genuine intellectual agility.
The implementation of these methods is a testament to the recognition that AI, while a powerful tool, cannot replicate the nuanced expression of human thought and creativity. The ability to articulate ideas coherently and legibly, especially under time constraints, is a crucial skill that transcends technological fluency. The emphasis on legible handwriting, in particular, speaks to a desire for authenticity and a return to the fundamentals of communication. While AI can generate text, it cannot replicate the personal touch and immediate expression conveyed through handwritten words.
This evolution in college admissions is not merely a reactionary measure against AI; it is a proactive step towards ensuring that students develop the essential skills needed to thrive in an increasingly complex world. It is a reminder that while technology can enhance learning, it should not replace the foundational skills that underpin effective communication. The ability to write legibly, think critically, and express oneself authentically are qualities that will remain invaluable, regardless of technological advancements.
As technology continues to reshape education, it is imperative that we strike a balance between digital literacy and the fundamental skills that define human communication. Colleges and universities are leading the charge in this endeavor, adapting their evaluation methods to ensure that students possess the critical thinking and writing abilities needed to succeed. The future of education lies not in choosing between technology and tradition, but in finding a harmonious integration that fosters both innovation and authenticity.
After AP Cal BC – Take Advanced Mathematics in the Age of A.I.
By James H. Choi
http://Column.SabioAcademy.com
Source URL
Only a small percentage of American high school students complete AP Calculus BC. As of 2024, about 87,000 students nationwide took this exam, representing just 3% of the approximately 3 million American high school graduates each year.
Mathematics Learning Paths for the AI Era
Students who complete AP Calculus BC before 12th grade now have more diverse options. In today’s AI-dominated era, conceptual understanding and application skills have become more important than calculation abilities, making various learning paths worth considering.
Advanced Data Science and Statistics
If you haven’t taken AP Statistics yet, you should. In the AI era, data interpretation skills are essential, with statistics forming the foundation. Bayesian statistics provides a framework for dealing with uncertainty, while experimental design teaches methodologies for obtaining meaningful results. Data mining techniques help discover patterns in large volumes of data.
It’s important to apply theoretical knowledge through real dataset analysis. Understanding concepts like hypothesis testing, confidence intervals, and regression analysis builds the foundation for data-driven decision making.
Concurrent Learning of Multivariable Calculus and Linear Algebra
Traditionally, students learned Multivariable Calculus before Linear Algebra. However, in the AI era, studying these subjects concurrently is advantageous. Gradient Descent, fundamental to deep learning algorithms, is a core concept in multivariable calculus, while neural network weight updates use matrix operations from linear algebra.
In computer vision, both fields are necessary when representing images as matrices. In natural language processing, techniques like word embeddings utilize vector spaces, requiring understanding of both vector operations and multivariable functions. Understanding optimization problems in machine learning requires comprehensive knowledge of both fields.
Discrete Mathematics and Algorithm Theory
Discrete Mathematics, previously important only to pure mathematics or computer science majors, is now essential for all STEM students. Graph theory forms the basis for applications like social network analysis, recommendation systems, and finding optimal paths. Combinatorics helps understand the decision space of AI systems.
Algorithm analysis provides a framework for evaluating efficiency and complexity, essential for optimizing AI performance. Boolean algebra and logic help understand decision processes and rule-based reasoning. Discrete probability theory forms the basis for AI models dealing with uncertainty, while information theory addresses entropy, a core concept in data compression and machine learning.
Computational Thinking and Programming
Beyond mathematical concepts, developing implementation skills in programming languages is important. Python is suitable for practicing mathematical concepts with its rich libraries for data analysis and machine learning. R is specialized for statistical analysis, while Julia is optimized for numerical computation.
“Computational Thinking” or “Mathematical Computing” courses teach how to decompose mathematical problems algorithmically and implement them in code. Coding matrix operations, numerical solutions of differential equations, and probability simulations helps connect theory and practice.
Practical Approaches
Modern mathematics learning requires balance between theory and practical application:
Project-Based Learning: Solving real problems using AI tools is effective. After learning differential equations, coding physics simulations (like pendulum motion or population growth models) applies theoretical concepts. Applying optimization algorithms to scheduling or resource allocation problems demonstrates practical applications. Analyzing real datasets builds data analysis skills.
Collaboration with AI Tools: Tools like ChatGPT, Wolfram Alpha, and GitHub Copilot should be collaborative partners for concept understanding and problem-solving. Wolfram Alpha helps verify visualizations and step-by-step solutions. ChatGPT provides various explanations to develop understanding. GitHub Copilot teaches different approaches to implementing algorithms. Critically reviewing these tools’ solutions deepens understanding.
Interdisciplinary Applications: Apply mathematics to physics, economics, biology, and social sciences. Physics uses differential equations to model natural phenomena. Economics applies game theory and optimization to decision-making. Biology uses probability theory and differential equations in population genetics and ecosystem modeling. Social sciences employ network theory and statistical methods to understand interactions and behavioral patterns.
Developing Mathematical Intuition: While AI performs calculations instantly, mathematical intuition and creative problem-solving remain uniquely human. Focus on the ‘why’ and ‘how’ to understand fundamental reasons and connections. Try different approaches to problems to develop varied perspectives. Focus on recognizing patterns and generalizing rather than memorizing techniques. Find counterexamples and consider extreme cases to explore theoretical limits. Visual representations strengthen intuitive understanding.
College and Career Preparation
Students who finish AP Calculus BC early can take courses at nearby colleges or through online platforms like edX, Coursera, and Khan Academy. Programs like Stanford’s “Math Camp,” MIT’s “PRIMES,” and Johns Hopkins’ “Center for Talented Youth” offer college-level mathematics experience. “Mathematical Modeling Competitions” and “Algorithm Competitions” develop problem-solving abilities.
Self-directed learning resources include MIT’s OpenCourseWare, Stanford’s online advanced mathematics courses, and Khan Academy. Programs like Coursera’s “Machine Learning” or edX’s “Data Science MicroMasters” apply mathematical knowledge to AI and data science.
For research experience, connect with professors or research institutes for internship opportunities. Many universities offer summer research programs for high school students.
In the AI era, mathematical modeling, algorithmic thinking, and creative application of mathematics are more important than calculation abilities. Designing learning paths to develop these competencies maintains competitiveness as AI technology advances. Mathematical intuition and creative problem-solving are uniquely human strengths that AI cannot easily replace.
Sabio Column 